I was at a gathering recently where it was announced that the hostess's favourite television show is "The Biggest Loser." I kind of cringed inwardly. This show is about monitoring overweight people as they struggle to lose weight.
In the past few weeks, as I have been watching shows on A&E, I have seen a commercial for a television show that features real live drug addicts struggling to overcome their issues. There is one clip from the commercial where a man and woman, apparently father and daughter, are crying and sobbing and being generally overly emotional. There is a voice over that has a woman sharing her love of heroin. Forgive me for not catching the title; I'm usually just so turned off by the commercial that I ignore it.
My kids tuned into the show "Hoarders" in the summer, and I watched for about five minutes as the crew of the show went through a man's yard, which was full of junk, and listened to him sob and experience genuine anxiety at the thought of parting with this stuff.
Wow. That's entertainment?
This kind of thing is, of course, not new. Oprah Winfrey, Jerry Springer, Maury Povich, and Dr. Phil all have had their share of tearful, emotional episodes which expose a family or an individual's angst and personal baggage for all the world to see. Ostensibly, this is to help them cope with it. Of course, it must occur to many that serious family issues, addictions, and dysfunctionality of all sorts may not be cured in the hour long television show, but doesn't it make for interesting viewing? We all love to see someone with more problems than we have. It appeals to our latent voyeuristic tendencies. These recent programs have simply brought the drama to prime time. Whether it is the Super Nanny program which teaches parents how to have common sense, or something more troubling, like "Hoarders," this is supposed to be entertainment.
Whatever happened to the day when people's dirty laundry was not aired out for all to see? I understand that in many instances, personal problems were an unnecessary source of shame for some, and they needed to be addressed openly. But open dialogue does not mean inviting millions of strangers into our homes to watch. There is no shame in having a personal problem, but when I make it a source of entertainment for others, in the name of "helping" them, what does that say about me? I'd say I should change my name to Narcissius.
The power of pity and dirty laundry is overwhelming. We have gone from hiding people's personal issues to glorying in the shame and dyfunction. How's that for deconstruction? Instead of being discreet about our problems, why not worship them and fuel them and tune in the sad stories of others?
We feel sorry for those poor people, and we tune into watch. What about the millions of other people with serious issues who DON'T get asked to be on Oprah or featured on "Extreme Home Makeover?" What are the criteria for choosing someone for that kind of thing? Just how desperate must one be, and how do they measure it? Is there a "poor, helpless, and desperate" scale out there somewhere? Is the most pathetic case the one that generates the most viewers? My goodness, we can't even have legal issues without without with out Judge Judy intervening. What's next? Watching someone in the bathroom? When I have seen such television shows, I have had pretty low opinions of the participants by the time the show is over.
I can feel sorry for myself with the best of them. I'm ashamed to admit it to myself. As a teenager, I can remember thinking that making someone feel sorry for me was somehow a punishment for the offending party. I believed that my "right" to feel victimized was an excuse for me to behave how I wanted. In reality, I had absolutely nothing to feel sorry for myself about. Ultimately, what does someone's pity or sympathy do for my situation? How does it help me deal with it? Constantly portraying myself as a "victim" is tempting, because then I can expect to be treated better than others. There are indeed real victims out there and they're probably the ones quietly living with it and would rather not be a victim.
It has often been my observation that those who have something to complain about are the most quiet about their sorrow and grief. Those who have a few hard things are out there singing the blues as loudly as they can. There are people in the world with real needs, real baggage, terrible circumstances and situations that would make me sit in the corner, catatonic. They're not on the television asking for "help." They're coping. The ones who are shouting, "Hey, look at me, and feel sorry for me," are in need of a swift kick in the posterior.
It is a strange way we regard entertainment in this day.